PCB Testing
The last thing customers want to see is that after the PCB assembly is completed, or even after the product assembly is completed, they find that there is a problem with the PCB, causing great losses. Even though the PCB design is perfect, the entire manufacturing process is complex and affected by many factors. There can be hundreds of components and solder joints on a board in thousands, and without adequate validation, a PCB can also exhibit poor functionality. Jhdpcb understands this, so we believe that testing printed circuit boards (PCBs) is very important, as testing can help detect problems at an early stage, increase yield and reduce costs, and improve overall quality and safety. Since every testing way with advantages and disadvantages, it is hard to say which one is best for your testing. To better understand how PCB testing can enhance PCB products,let’s learn more about the benefits of PCB testing as well as the various ways to test PCBs.
The Benefits of PCB Testing.
Find bugs: The main benefit of PCB testing is that it can effectively recognize bugs in the PCB. Whether the problem is functional, manufacturable, or otherwise, PCB testing identifies issues in PCB design and layout so designers can make adjustments accordingly.
Reduce costs: PCB testing prevents waste from producing defective products by using prototyping and small-quatities assemblies to test products. By accomplishing overall testing early in the design procedure, designers can prevent the bulk production of defective PCBs, in order to ensure the design is as perfect as possible before it goes into production This step helps to reduce production costs significantly.
Saves time: In the long run, early-stage PCB testing helps save time, to allow designers to recognize major problem during the prototyping step. Complete testing enables designers to quickly and easily discover the root cause of problems and make adjustments so they can continue production faster and reduce product lead times.
Reduced return rate: When a company conducts PCB testing, it can effectively reduce the chance of selling defective products or products that do not meet performance standards. This reduces costs associated with refunding customers and handling defective merchandise.In addition, reducing returns can make better customer satisfaction and company reputation enhanced.
Improved safety: Because PCBs are often used in fundamental electronics technology, their nonsuccess result in significant problems for a company’s productive forces or an Organizational skills. Defective PCBs may cause accidents such as fire, and in severe cases may cause injuries to nearby workers. Pre-manufacturing testing also ensures that machines and workers are not damaged or injured by improper design during production.
Although thorough testing of all types of PCBs is not required, especially ones that are already technically mature. But most new and custom PCB designs require regular testing of the design procedure. JHD provides customers with high quality and reliable PCBs by establishing proper PCB testing procedures for their needs.
What Does PCB Testing Check?
The purpose of PCB testing and inspection is to check whether the PCB conforms to standard printed circuit board performance. Ensure that all PCB manufacturing processes are functioning properly to project specifications and are free of any defects.
A PCB consists of different components and assemblies, each of which affects the overall function of an printed circuit board. These elements are analysed in detail to keep PCB quality well. The test content to be performed should include the following checks:
- Lamination: Lamination quality is critical to the longevity of a PCB. Peeling laminate can directly cause problems with board functionality. Typically, lamination tests are used to test the resistance of laminates to peeling by force or heat;
- Pore Wall Quality: Pore walls are typically analyzed in environments with cycling and rapid temperature changes to understand how they respond to thermal effects. Make sure that the hole walls do not crack or delaminate when the PCB is put into service.
- Copper Plating: The copper foil on the PCB is attached to the PCB board to support conductivity. Test the quality of copper, detailed analysis of tensile strength and elongation.
- Cleanliness: The cleanliness of a PCB is a measure of the board’s ability to withstand environmental factors such as weatherability, corrosion and humidity.
- Solderability: Materials are tested for solderability to make sure that components can be fixed stably to the board and prevent soldering defects in the final product.
- Electrical Testing: Conductivity is essential to any PCB, and the ability to measure the minimum leakage current of a PCB is essential. For detailed electrical testing content and methods, please refer to “Comprehensive Understanding Of PCB E-Testing“.
- Cleanliness: The cleanliness of a PCB is a test of the board’s ability to resist environmental factors such as corrosion and humidity.
- Environmental Testing: This is a performance and quality change test for the PCB to run in a humid environment. A weight comparison is usually made before and after placing the PCB in a wet environment, and a significant weight change is considered a rejection.
Eight Most Common PCB Testing Methods.
Visual inspection:
Visual inspection is part of the visual inspection, which is a manual manual test method that requires an experienced inspector to use a magnifying glass or microscope to check for weld defects and other visible defects with the naked eye. Visual inspection is suitable for visual inspection of circuit boards, seemingly poor solder mask application, component orientation or scratch smudges can all lead to circuit board failure.
Benefit:
Inexpensive and easy to operate – no test fixtures or complicated setup required;
Most major welding defects can be identified.
Shortcoming:
subject to human error. This may be decided by the skill of the technician;
Only visible solder joints can be inspected, hidden solder joints cannot be evaluated;
Time consuming, laborious, inconsistent.
Automatic Optical Inspection (AOI):
AOI inspection can reduce PCB bugs or defects on an beginning development step. AOI using a single (2D) or two (3D) camera to capture high-resolution images of the PCB board, and the program comparing these images to a detailed schematic or database of good or bad board images to find defects. AOI is often used as the first step in quality assurance. Make sure that problems are detected early and that production stops as soon as possible.
Different types of defects can be detected, and if the board does not match the schematic to some extent, the board is marked for inspection by a technician. Click to view detailed AOI inspection content.
Never depend only on AOI,automated optical inspection should be used in mixed with other tests. Some of the combinations that JHDPCB recommends to offer are:
AOI and flying probe;
AOI and online testing (ICT);
AOI and functional testing.
Benefit:
Most major welding defects can be identified.
More truly and precisely than manual visual inspection.
Applying in production line for defects detection at early stage .
Shortcoming:
AOI is a passive testing method – only surface defects can be detected.
Limited line-of-sight control to detect connections hidden by BGA or other parts.
100% coverage of all part types is not possible.
The setup and programming of template matching is time-consuming and has to be re-done for every design change.
Database matching may not be as accurate and reply on the quality of the database.
Online Test (ICT):
PCBA ICT is currently the most powerful and popular type of PCBA testing for high volume and mature products, and is a popular PCB testing method trusted by many PCB manufacturers and customers. Its fault extent to 95%. During PCB assembly ICT, electrical probes in the form of a nails bed send current through specific position on the board at designated testing points. These tests are used to verify the correct function, location, orientation and defects of each electronic component on the PCB. The test includes the verification of parameters such as short circuit, open circuit, resistance, capacitance, etc. The nails bed tester simply pushes the PCB board down onto the probe bed to start testing. Access points are pre-engineered on the circuit board to allow ICT test probes to connect to the circuit.
For high-volume or repeat batches, custom test fixtures can be made for faster and more efficient in-circuit testing. This test method is expensive, and the price will depend on factors such as board and fixture size. Therefore, it is strongly not recommended that you change your mind and move to an ICT strategy during production.
This testing way with special PCB testing procedures and equipment, including:
In-Circuit Tester: A tester system involve hundreds or thousands of arrays of drivers and sensors to perform test measurements.
Fixture: The fixture is connected to the in-circuit tester and is the component that directly interacts with the circuit board under test. This fixture seem like a nails bed and is designed for the particular circuit board.Every “nail” or sensor point is connected to the corresponding point on the PCB testing board, then feed back signal information to the in-Circuit tester.Fixtures are usually the most expensive part of the system.
Software: The software for the tester instructs the system which tests to perform on each type of board under test, and indicates pass or fail parameters.
Benefit:
The fault coverage rate can be as high as 98%;
Efficient and rapid testing methods for mass-produced products.
Shortcoming:
Test fixtures are an additional cost.
Not applicable to do low-quantity production or prototyping order, since any changes to the design file result in remaking the testing fixture.
Only test points are accessible, and the designer have to add testing points to the board.
Certain defects, such as too much or not enough solder, voids, cannot be evaluated.
Flying Probe Test (FPT):
Similar in nature to traditional ICT work, flying probe testing is often seen as an improved version of bed of needles ICT. In addition to test points, the flying probe machine can access uncovered component itself just like test points, and can be programmed to check the values of passive components, directly check diode orientation and perform voltage measurements . Ability to adapt new boards quickly, cheaply and efficiently with simpler programming changes. This testing method makes it ideal for low-volume production testing and prototype testing, but is slow and not cost-effective for large-scale production.
The flying probe test is used to check:
Open, shorts, revolt, capacitance, impedance control, inductance, diode problems.
Benefit:
It is cheaper and faster to implement or modify. No fixtures required.
Wider testing coverage – Vias and component pads could be used as testing points.
Not required to add testing points. Save space.
Shortcoming:
Testing is too slow for large scale testing
Certain defects, such as too much or not enough solder, voids, cannot be evaluated.
Automated X-ray Inspection (AXI):
X-ray testing of the PCB is required when there are solder joints or pads for lead-free components that are not visible through a microscope or with the naked eye. X-rays can penetrate PCBs and component bodies, producing 2D or even 3D images of solder joints. This makes it ideal for inspecting hidden joints such as connections with solder joints under chip packages and ball grid array packages. AXI inspection can also test pseudo soldering, that different from many other optical inspection ways. While this inspection can be very useful, it requires a trained and experienced operator. JHD has specially skilled and trained staff to perform this operation, and you can deliver your PCB project to us with confidence.
When used with a production process, AXI can be used for early testing of defects, By makeing process adjustments to reduce the source of the problem. During this test, X-ray technicians were able to locate defects early in the manufacturing process by looking at:
Solder connection
Internal traces
Barrels
Benefit:
Can have the highest defect detection rate among common inspection methods;
Highlight long-life soldering joint quality, not only connections.
Shortcoming:
Requires trained and experienced operators;
Very time consuming and expensive process.
Burn-in (environmental) testing:
Burn-in testing is a more intensive type of PCB testing that can help you check performance and uncover hidden defects before your board is put into service. During the burn-in test, the burn-in test may cause damage to the component under test due to the test intensity. The circuit board is subjected to conditions exceeding the rated operating conditions to check out early faults and test the load capacity to clear up early faults in actual use. Power is pushed through other electronics, typically through the board at maximum rated current for 48 to 170 hours of continuous operation. Of course, not every PCB product needs to be subjected to burn-in testing, and it will only play its role in PCB projects with specific requirements and environments.
The operate conditions of the testing may involve in temperature, current, voltage, operating frequency or any other operating conditions related to the design. By collecting data in this process can help engineers better understand defects reason and optimize the design before manufacturing process.
Benefit:
Check performance under real-world conditions of use (something that other tests can’t achieve);
Better product reliability.
Shortcoming:
The testing process may shorten the life time of the product;
reduce overall production;
A time-consuming and labor-intensive process.
Functional Test (FCT):
Functional testing is the last step in the manufacturing process, and a functional tester is used to check whether the finished PCB functions properly. This doesn’t check out if the board is good, the presence of solder, or part tolerances. The circuits are properly powered and electrically excited through the interface connector, verifying their compliance with the design specification.
According to the complicacy of the design and the particular test requirements, the functional testing can be a simple switching power supply testing or a overall testing with strict protocols and test software. Because of its flexibility, functional testing can be used to replace more expensive testing procedures. Functional testing imitate the real operating environment and can therefore be more straightforward than other testing ways. Complete 100% functional testing is increasingly used in low-volume manufacturing to ensure that every board that comes off the production line is functioning properly.
Benefit:
Discover potential circuit anomalies;
measure the power absorption at a specific point in the circuit;
Flexible and highly customizable, almost all types of PCBs can be tested;
Lower cost and more convenient than other testing ways which need customized equipment.
Shortcoming:
The rate of defect detection reply on the inspections covered by the test plan;
The need for trained technicians to isolate the cause of the defect;
Under different stresses, the PCB boards may short circuit after passing the functional testing. Therefore, complex PCBs will also be tested with aging tests.
Boundary Scan Test:
Boundary-scan testing is a technique suitable for testing interconnections between components on a PCB. In this kind of testing, batteries are placed in leads from the silicon die to external pins to test the functionality of the board.
The biggest difference with this way of testing is able to detect the board without reaching all nodes. This quality is important for evaluating integrated circuits with multiple layers and high densities, as these types of PCBs have become more common in recent years.
In fact, this test method is so versatile that it can be used for a variety of applications, including functions such as system-level testing, memory testing, flash programming, and central processing unit (CPU) emulation. It is often used in field service to detect problems in functional systems.
Other Types of PCB Assembly Testing:
In addition to the common test methods listed above, other types of PCB assembly testing include:
Microsection Analysis: Investigate defects,shorts, opens, and other failures.
Solderability Testing: Ensures a solid surface and increases the chance of a reliable solder joint.
Peel Test: Find out the strength measurement required to peel the laminate from the board.
PCB Contamination Testing: Detects high levels of ions that can contaminate circuit boards, causing corrosion and other problems.
Time Domain Reflectometry (TDR): Find faults in high-frequency boards.
Solder Float Testing: Defines the stress thermal that a PCB hole can withstand.
What Factors Determine Testing Methods?
There are several factors that determine the choice of testing methods for printed circuit boards (PCBs). These factors include:
- Budget:
The available budget will play a significant role in determining the testing methods that can be used. Some testing methods, such as Flying Probe Test, may be more cost-effective for low to medium-volume production runs, while other methods, such as In-Circuit Test, may be more suitable for high-volume production runs, but come with a higher upfront cost. - Lead Time:
The lead time required for testing the PCB is another important factor to consider when choosing a testing method. Some methods, such as Automated Optical Inspection (AOI), can provide faster testing times than others, such as X-Ray Inspection, which may require more time to set up and perform. - Expected Volume:
The expected volume of PCB production can also impact the choice of testing methods. For high-volume production runs, methods such as the In-Circuit probe Test may be more suitable, as they can quickly test large quantities of PCBs. For lower-volume production runs, methods such as FCT may be more suitable due to their flexibility and lower setup costs. - PCB complexity:
The printed circuit board complexity is also a crucial factor in determining the suitable testing methods. For example, PCBs with a large number of components, high-density designs, or complex circuitry may require more advanced testing methods, such as ICT or Boundary Scan Test, to ensure that all components are tested thoroughly.
Other factors that can influence the choice of testing methods include the type of components used, the required level of testing accuracy, and the specific industry or application for which the PCB is being used.
What Attributes Does PCB Testing Contain?
Bare Board Test Properties:
- Humidity: It primarily happens for circuit boards with applications that require humid environments. This test involves subjecting the PCB to a measure of its water absorption capacity. The PCB is weighed before and after being exposed to a humid environment, and any substantial weight change may indicate failure to meet the required standards.
- Lamination Testing: Lamination Testing is crucial in determining the lifespan of a printed circuit board as it heavily relies on the quality of lamination. Poor lamination can lead to functionality issues, such as delamination, in which the laminate peels off. Tests are conducted to measure the resistance of the laminate to peeling when subjected to heat or force.
- Electrical Conductivity: One of the essential aspects of a printed circuit board is its electrical conductivity, making it a critical test subject. The ability of a PCB to efficiently conduct electric current without excessive leakage is crucial.
- Environmental testing: Environmental Testing refers to the process of evaluating PCBs for their ability to withstand environmental conditions like humidity and corrosion. This testing involves subjecting the PCBs to environmental conditions and analyzing them for any changes before and after exposure to determine their resistance. Also, the tests follow a similar route to environmental testing.
- Copper Plating: Copper plating is a vital element of a circuit board, and its elongation and tensile strength are tested to ensure its quality. Copper is often laminated on the circuit board to provide conductivity.
- Hole Wall Value: Hole Wall Value is a crucial quality parameter of a printed circuit board, as it helps prevent cracking or delamination when the PCB is deployed in the field. This parameter requires analysis for cycling and rapidly changing temperatures to gauge the reaction to thermal stress.
Assembled Component Properties:
- Reliability Testing: Reliability testing involves testing the board’s ability to function correctly over an extended period, including stress testing and accelerated aging tests. It also includes testing for welding reliability.
- Electrical Testing: This involves checking the board’s electrical characteristics, such as resistance, capacitance, and impedance, to ensure that they meet the required standards. It also includes testing for resistance voltage adaptability.
- Solderability Tests: Solderability tests aim to eliminate defects in the final product and ensure the proper attachment of components. These tests analyze critical factors such as wetting, which determines the surface’s receptiveness to liquid solder.
Whichever method is chosen, PCB testing is a necessary step in the board design and manufacturing process, saving a lot of unnecessary time and cost in identifying defects that could affect a circuit before it goes into final production. In general, a suitable combination of the above inspection and testing methods can detect all possible defects, the cost of which depends on the specific application and complexity of the circuit under test. However, to successfully run tests on your PCB or PCBA, you need a trusted supplier to ensure your prototypes are built to order every time. JHDPCB will provide rigorous inspection and testing procedures for all circuit boards we supply to ensure the quality of the final product – including bare board fabrication and assembled PCBs. A full line of state-of-the-art equipment offers a variety of prototype and small-scale production services to help you speed up your testing process. With years of professionalism and no hidden fees, you can fully trust us to provide you with high-quality prototypes for your next round of PCB testing. Contact JHD today for a quote!
